Please Pass the Recipe

sharing recipes from one generation to the next

Mrs Beeton’s Caramel Pudding


The Cookbook Guru, hosted by Leah is exploring Mrs Beeton’s classic tome on cooking and household management during May.

I inherited a 1907 copy of “Mrs Beeton’s Family Cookery” from my dearly cherished Grandma Lois. She was born in 1899 in England, Yorkshire to be exact. Orphaned at four years of age. Lois and her baby brother were sent to Norfolk to be raised by their kindly grandparents who were poor farm labourers. The untimely death of their Grandmother forced 12 year old Lois into domestic service.

In her ninties, Grandma was encouraged to write about her experiences as a house maid, kitchen maid, cook and housekeeper. She wrote about laying rising early to blacken the stove while it was cool and scrubbing floors on her hands and knees, but mainly her memories were dominated by terrible working conditions, petty staff jealousies and exploitive employers. Mrs Beeton’s advice on matters domestic gives me a practical insight into Grandma’s working life.

Life for Lois changed when she saw an advertisement encouraging domestic staff to emigrate to Australia. She sailed to Melbourne in 1926, met20140504-203753.jpg my Grandfather on the voyage and the rest, as they say, is history.

Grandma was a frugal by nature, her humble beginnings ensured that never changed. She had a well earned reputation for her silky baked custards, never made with cream, but simply with whole milk.I don’t have Grandma’s tried and true formula for baked caramel custard, but it may well have been taken from her copy of Mrs Beeton’s cookbook.

I set out to follow the recipe for Mrs Beeton’s caramel pudding faithfully. The tiny quantity of caramel made to the recipe’s instructions went from beginning to burnt in about 20 seconds, so I had to make a second batch, but not before consulting a modern recipe for quantities.

The second batch made just enough to coat the inside of 8x125ml ramekins and 1x250ml dish. After the frustrating beginning to making caramel pudding the remainder of the recipe was pretty straightforward, and clear to follow.

I preheated the oven to 160C, without the fan, but when I opened the door to put the custard in to cook, I sensed the temperature was still too high so I reduced it a further 10 degree. I think I should have reduced it further again as the cooked custards, sadly, had tiny bubbles around the edges which spoilt their texture. Modern day ovens are so much more efficient than they were a century ago.  They are not subject to the vagaries of solid fuel and they so well insulated that the temperature remains constant. I have amended the recipe to take this into consideration.

As well as the issues with the caramel and the oven heat, I do wish that the recipe had stated what sized dishes to use. The small size I cooked were a bit smaller than those intended, a delicious tiny sweet taste, but I should have monitored the time in the oven a little more closely.

When it’s all said and done this was a classic creme caramel with a lighter custard than the French style. We thoroughly enjoyed these desserts. Having ironed out the issues with the original recipe I’ll definitely make them again.
1 cup castor sugar
1/2 cup water cold water

600mls whole milk (I used lactose free)
2 eggs
2 egg yolks extra
1 tablespoon castor sugar
1/2 vanilla bean

Preheat the oven to 140C.
Whisk together the whole eggs, yolks and sugar. Gradually whisk in the milk then strain the custard to remove any lumps of egg white. Whisk in the seeds scraped from the vanilla bean. Set aside.
Bring the sugar and water to the boil in a small saucepan, stirring continuously until the sugar is dissolved. Continue to boil the syrup until it caramelizes to a golden colour.
Immediately tip some caramel into the base of 4x250ml deep sided ovenproof ramekins, then quickly swirl the coat the sides before the toffee solidifies.
When the toffee is set, fill the dishes with the custard mixture.
Put the dishes in a deep baking pan and fill the pan with hot water so it comes 3/4 of the way up the sides of the dishes.
Bake for approximately 40 minutes, or until cooked in the middle. To test the custard, slip a sharp paring knife into the centre of the custard and see that it is set.
Remove the custards from the oven and the baking dish and allow to cool.
Chill before turning out and serving.

The Original Recipe
INGREDIENTS.- For the caramel : 2 ozs of loaf sugar, 2 tablespoons of cold water. For the custard: 1/2 pint of milk, 4 yolks and 2 whites of eggs, 1 tablespoon of castor sugar, a few drops of vanilla or other flavouring.
METHOD.- Boil the loaf sugar and cold water together until the liquid acquires a light brown colour, then pour it into a charlotte or plain timbale mould, and turn the mould slowly round and round until every part of it is coated in the caramel. Beat the eggs, add to them the sugar, flavouring and milk, and stir until the sugar is dissolved. Strain the custard into the mould, cover with a greased paper, steam very slowly for about 40 minutes, then turn out carefully. No other sauce is needed than the caramel, which runs off when the pudding is inverted. This pudding is equally nice cold; when intended to be served thus, it may be allowed to cool before being turned out of the mould, and so lessen the probability of it breaking. If preferred, 6 dariol moulds may be used instead of 1 large mould.
TIME.- About 1 1/4 hours. AVERAGE COST, 7d. or 8d. SUFFICIENT for 4 or 5 persons.



About ladyredspecs

I live in sunny Brisbane, Australia. My love of good food drives me as a cook, a reader, a traveller, an artist and but mostly as an eater. I cooked professionally for many years but have no formal training. Simply guided by a love of eating good food, respect for ingredients and an abhorrence of artificial additives, I cook instinctively applying the technical know how acquired by experience. I hope you enjoy what I share Sandra AKA ladyredspecs

16 comments on “Mrs Beeton’s Caramel Pudding

  1. Pingback: Bread and Butter Pudding | Please Pass the Recipe

  2. Francesca
    May 27, 2014

    I just noticed this post – it must have appeared when I was in NZ. I notice you too have very fond memories of your grandmother and I especially enjoyed reading about her. I love creme caramel and have made numerous versions over the years. This one looks just about perfect and is identical to Stephanie Alexander’s recipe in ‘Menus for Food Lovers’ which turned up in Savers last week for $2.99.
    I wish I could focus on packing!


    • ladyredspecs
      May 27, 2014

      What a bargain. I’ll check out her cooking temps for some future guidance. My Grandma lived into her 99th year with all her faculties. After such a rough beginning, family was her life. Now concentrate!


  3. Leah
    May 9, 2014

    Reblogged this on The Cookbook Guru and commented:

    Lady Red Specs has contributed a classic recipe for us in the form of a creme caramel… and in the process shared a beautiful story of our (I’m her daughter for anyone not aware of that) family history that is very much embeded in the tales told in Mrs Beeton’s Book of Good Housekeeping.


  4. nancy@jamjnr
    May 9, 2014

    Now there’s something I’ve never mdd before but when my Mum makes creme caramel we can’t get enough. I like the idea of using milk over cream especially since I live with a walking cholesterol bomb!


    • ladyredspecs
      May 9, 2014

      Well, I made these with lactose free skimmed milk and they were lusciously creamy, all those yolks I suppose. They were actually quite simple once I ironed our the caramel


  5. laurasmess
    May 9, 2014

    Mrs Beeton’s!! Classic! I’ve never actually tasted anything from a Mrs Beeton book but I love this introduction that you’ve provided. The caramel pudding looks delicious… well done on your persistence! x


    • ladyredspecs
      May 9, 2014

      Thanks Laura, there was quite a bit of sentiment attached to trying this recipe. It wasn’t my finest hour, but the flavour was really wonderful so I intend to try again soon


  6. bakeritalia
    May 8, 2014

    They look great, when I make them I cook them at 120 and pop a tea towel in the water for the ramikens to sit on which help with the texture of the custard.


    • ladyredspecs
      May 8, 2014

      Thanks so much for the advice, we loved them so much, I’ll be making caramel custard again very soon, and I want them to be perfect! The old recipe seemed a bit hit and miss by modern standards!


  7. Selma's Table
    May 8, 2014

    Oh my goodness – that looks absolutely fantastic! It was worth persevering!


  8. My Kitchen Witch
    May 8, 2014

    Excellent recipe and I love how you persisted to get it right. Quantities and cooking methods in those old cookbooks are the hardest things to cope with. Funny, my grandmother was a maid and then cook before she married my grandfather – although she obviously didn’t migrate to Australia!


    • ladyredspecs
      May 8, 2014

      The custard got too hot, the texture was bubbly but because I’m a perfectionist, I will make them again, they were a delicious treat!


  9. marymtf
    May 8, 2014

    Seven pence! What can you buy for seven pence these days?


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.


This entry was posted on May 8, 2014 by in Desserts, Food, Gluten Free, Light dessert, The Cookbook Guru and tagged , , , .
%d bloggers like this: